“They don’t value life”: How empire dehumanizes its victims, from Indigenous genocide to Vietnam to Palestine
While sharing the text of the Declaration of Independence, NPR accidentally highlighted racist lines we conveniently never hear from nationalists, on “the merciless Indian Savages, whose known rule of warfare is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions.”
and has endeavoured to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian Savages,
— NPR (@NPR) July 4, 2017
whose known rule of warfare, is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions.
— NPR (@NPR) July 4, 2017
This drivel in the US government’s founding document is a centuries-old racist myth that we hear endlessly: “They don’t value life. But we do.” It is a talking point that helps to dehumanize the victims of empire.
One of the most infamous examples of this obscene projection is a scene in the 1974 documentary Hearts and Minds, featuring General William Westmoreland, who led US forces as they slaughtered civilians in Vietnam.
US general who led mass-murdering war in Vietnam (3.8M dead) claimed "The Oriental doesn't put the same high price on life as a Westerner" pic.twitter.com/WsTaeeb7iK
— Ben Norton (@BenjaminNorton) July 5, 2017
“The Oriental doesn’t put the same high price on life as does a Westerner,” Westmoreland insisted. “Life is plentiful; life is cheap in the Orient. The philosophy of the Orient expresses that life is not important.”
Filmmaker Peter Davis juxtaposed these comments with the US military dropping napalm on civilians, with Vietnamese children and mothers sobbing as they mourn the deaths of their family.
Up to 3.8 million Vietnamese died in the 20-year US war, which verged on genocidal.
The scene in Hearts and Minds is followed up with an interview in which a US soldier admits that it was in fact they who did not value life.
Today, Palestinians are frequently smeared with this same talking point. Zionists claim Palestinians “do not value the lives of their people” — as they support an apartheid regime that kills and militarily occupies Palestinians.
Israel’s chief of police insisted, “There is a difference between our grief and their grief… Our enemies chose to sanctify death.”
Imperialists maintain that Muslims as a whole “love death” — whereas only the “enlightened” Westerners bombing Muslims truly value life.
Edward Said wrote in 1994 of how the US media “routinely lingers over Israeli grief during funerals after a violent action, and just as routinely ignores any such sequence on the Palestinian side, as if to confirm the supposition that Palestinians do not suffer, do not value life as ‘we’ do.”
Racism is how empire tries to justify itself. For centuries the US has insisted its enemies don’t value life — while it kills their children.
Likewise, the hallowed US Founding Fathers claimed “Indian savages” carried out “undistinguished destruction of all ages” as they were the ones committing genocide against Indigenous peoples in this country. A staggering 100 million Natives died during European colonization.
This is the projection of empire: blame the victims of the very inhumanity you yourself exude.